The semester is over. My on campus jobs are over. I have a couple weeks to relax and then - on to research fellowship. The reading has begun, but the data collection will wait until June.
In the meantime I’ll be hanging out on Elmwood, at various locations, hopefully getting a bit of writing done for my wonderful readers here at Rise Up Buffalo. I know I often make promises that I cannot live up to when it comes up to this site, so I’m not going to be doing that today. I hope to make a few posts on events and such throughout the summer, but again - no promises.
Today, however, I would like to discuss an interesting social phenomenon that I have been recently acquainted with. Tween literature. Specifically, the clique books. While perusing the bookstore on Saturday evening, I found that there are a plethora of book series for tweens and teens. The two main themes of these book series are vampires and mean girls (or often a combination of the two). Throw in the fact that most of the characters are rich (and the one character in each series that is not rich gets the brunt of the mean girls wrath) and you have a recipe for disaster.
Since parents are so busy these days, trying to keep up with the Joneses, it makes it difficult to read everything that their tweens/teens are consuming. This most often results in kids reading whatever they want and parents not monitoring content. Now, I’m not saying that we didn’t have teen books in the 80’s and 90’s that our parents let us read without censorship, but the themes in Judy Blume and Beverly Cleary books were a lot less trivial and mean-spirited. Yes, there were antagonistic characters (what book would be good without them) but they weren’t attacking each other for issues of monetary wealth. Lessons learned in these books focused on becoming a better person through the trials of the characters. The girls were mean, but they were shown as being wrong in their treatment of others. The clique books don’t seem to send the same message. The girls are mean and that is the way they are. They don’t learn lessons and, in fact, they are oftentimes rewarded for their ability to secure their level of superiority over their peers.
I am not against sexual education. In fact, I am all for teaching young adults about safe sex through literature, however I am against the framing of rich, snobiness as an okay way to behave. Learning a lesson through this behavior would be fine, however the clique girls (and the gossip girls) never seem to learn that lesson. They end up getting what they want and going about their business as if it is okay to treat others with disrespect and continue being popular. This sends a message to tweens that they need to act a certain way to gain popularity, and that way is to treat everyone else as if they are lower socially, physically, and monetarily. Bad message, right?
The author of the books claims that the subject matter (and the obsession of the characters with expensive, designer clothing) is tongue-in-cheek. That’s cool if the tweens who read the books get that it is a joke. That the characters are meant to be read as wrong and over the top and that the tweens who read the books should aspire to be better and different than the characters. However, I have a feeling that this is not the case. I know one middle school girl, in particular, who has taken the clique books seriously. She has decided that she needs to be like these girls in order to be popular and well liked. This will, most likely, be the downfall of her middle school popularity since kids in western new york (yes, even in amherst, williamsville, and clarence) are not like new york city kids. They are obsessed with being better than each other, but not necessarily to the degree of showing it thoroughly through clothing. They are, on the most part, still regular kids. One can get away with being cool without wearing designer clothing. The girls in the clique books are not able to maintain popularity without the “right” clothes, but kids in Buffalo can. That is a perk of growing up somewhere that is not as obsessed with money and status.
I have to admit that I have not read these books. However - I plan to do a study of tween literature as soon as I finish my current project. I’m thinking about doing a content analysis of the books and then, possibly, interviewing a few tweens from different backgrounds that have read the books to see what their perceptions of the literature are. This may end up showing that the books are not that harmful and that perceptions of lifestyle from the perspective of different classes can skew the true meanings in the books. Alternatively, it could show that the books, themselves, are actually skewing tween and teen perceptions of reality. It isn’t fair to judge without empirical evidence, so I will gather that before moving forward with my critique. I just wanted to put this out there and let you ponder it for a bit.
Peace -
Chantale
appropriate links:
Lisi Harrison discusses her clique book series
Beverly Cleary Books - still awesome
Judy Blume - still some of the best books for tweens - where would we be today without “Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing” and “Are You There God, It’s Me Margaret?”
Gossip Girl Books
The Vampire Diaries Fansite
House of Night Series
If you enjoyed this post, please pass it along to others!